Nepali journalism should learn lessons from Anuja scandal and move forward, rather than ridiculing a group of newspapers (or counter-attacking those who choose to ridicule) because this is the state of Nepali journalism – not only of a reporter or a newspaper
The Story
Nepal’s top national daily Kantipur and it’s sister publication The Kathmandu Post published a news report on its frontpage anchor position about Anuja Baniya who returned 9.1 million rupees and a diamond necklace to the owner after finding them abandoned in a public bus. President Dr Ram Baran Yadav himself called her to thank her – a news that was carried by almost all newspapers with backgrounder as published by Kantipur.
Soon after, there were news that stated police is investigating. The news turned out to be fake one and Kantipur did a praiseworthy job by publishing apology on frontpage stating that the story was untrue as the characters misled then.
The Aftermath
Suddenly everyone started seeing flaws in the story. The story was unbalanced, the story didn’t meet the basic criteria of fact-checking or ABC or 5WH according to journalistic principles. There were opinion articles and statuses on social media ridiculing Kantipur and/or journalism.
The old questionable news of past were thrown up in the air to prove that Nepali media are still infant. And, yes, there were some defenses for Kantipur.
Mistake? O, yes.
It was a mistake by Kantipur, there is no doubt about it. Given that Kantipur is the top daily of Nepal with huge impact, it could have done a little more fact-checking.
But to expect any media not to make mistake at all is not justifiable. As in any other sectors, journalists/media too learn from mistakes and when mistakes happens occasionally in media of countries like USA which has the long history of professional media and resources; mistake in Nepali media is certainly undesirable but not completely unavoidable given the short history, skills, and resources.
A step forward
As far as I know the apology published by Kantipur is the first honest acceptance of mistake in Nepali media. Some of the media have previously published apologies, most of the time going by the decision from Press Council of Nepal, but none were published as prominently as that of Kantipur’s.
This shows the professional honesty of Kantipur and this is certainly a step forward. Like it or not, they again proved the leader in Nepali journalism.
More mistakes
While constructive criticism focused on way-forward to Nepali media or lessons learned from the scandal were natural expectations from the pens of the media critics, they rather wasted their energy, ink and space of newspapers on preaching on media’s role and/or ridiculing Kantipur and/or criticizing Nepali journalism.
This, I take as more mistakes. It would have been valuable, and acceptable, had the critics raised the questions on the news as soon as it was published, or before police starting investigation, or even before Kantipur published the apology. When it is done after the apology, with focus on ridiculing journalism and/or Kantipur, rather that showing the way-forward, it looks a lame and biased writing.
Nepali journalism has a long way to go, but the media critics have still a longer road to go.
0 responses to “Nepali journalism around Anuja scandal”
nice 1…..i like this
Kantipur’s apology regarding the Anuja Baniya case is indeed laudable. The reactions however are not so encouraging. Perhaps reading the case of Jayson Blair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jayson_Blair
and NYT’s beautifully written apology on its reportings regarding the presence of WMD in Iraq http://www.nytimes.com/2004/05/26/international/middleeast/26FTE_NOTE.html?pagewanted=all would make people lashing at the media house to think more before they comment. Kantipur could also have elaborated a bit about how the grave error took place to make things more clear. However, this is not to say it makes their apology less significant.
Nonetheless readers or so called experts lashing out at journalists regarding this case exposes another deep-seated cause behind it. Journalism as a profession might be portrayed as ‘glamorous’ in recent times but it still isn’t considered respectable in the Nepali society to the extent it should be. The respect exists only if the people or institutions in concern need the support of the media or do what they think supports their cause. When the need is over and the media has a different stance everyone who can read and write seem to ooze with the confidence that s/he can do a journalist’s job. People seem to get a kick out of criticizing journalists or the media at large. At times people take it as their ultimate goal to have media persons kowtow before them. Armed with this mentality, the slightest error (in this case it was serious) has people lambasting the profession. Unless people learn to respect the profession and secondly realize that grave errors can be committed ( eg. NYT case) by anyone we cannot hope for a constructive criticism on this front. We don’t have a culture of appreciating anyone who admits their mistakes which only aggravates the situation.
And I fully agree with your last line ” Nepali journalism has a long way to go, but the media critics have still a longer road to go.” Well said!
Like!! I blog frequently and I really thank you for your content. The article has truly peaked my interest.
Likely I am likely to save your blog post. 🙂
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Ion Magnum ???????????????????????? , ????????????? , ??????????????? ??? ???????????????????????????25?????????????????????? ???/??? ????????????????????????????I??I?????????????????????????????? ????? ??????????????????????????????Ion Magnum????????????????(?????????????????????????????????? ?????????????????????10?????3-7????????????????????
Venus Viva™????????????????????Nano Fractional Radio Frequency™(??????™??Smart Scan™(????™????????????????????????????Nano Fractional RF™???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????:????????????????????????????????????????? ???????
Amma Garden ???? ????????????????????? Amma Garden ????,????,??????????
You have observed very interesting details! ps decent internet site. 🙂
CLINIQUE ?????????????, Clinique, ???,??,??,??,??,??, ,?????, ??, ???, ??, ???????,????,?????,??,????,???,3??
ARTISTRY ?? ?????????????? ARTISTRY INTENSIVE SKINCARE????? ARTISTRY ??,??????,?????? ARTISTRY INTENSIVE SKINCARE
???????????????????
BVLGARI ??? ???????????????????? BVLGARI ???,????????,?????
NEAUVIA??????????????????56??????????????????????????21?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????NEAUVIA?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????PEG????-???
Katerina???????•Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle: ???? ????, Katerina???????•Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle: ????, Katerina???????•Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle
(??) ???? X ??????? X ?????? X ???? @ ???????? ???????????? PIXstyleMe (??) ???? X ??????? X ?????? X ????
Bournemouth remain hopeful of landing Leeds United midfielder Lewis Cook this month. The Premier League side are ready to splash yet more cash in their quest for survival. Bournemouth keen on Leeds star Lewis Cook and remain hopeful of sealing deal
While Liverpool fans spent the aftermath of Monday night’s gritty derby game glowing after a very late winner from Sadio Mane, Jurgen Klopp’s players were also eager to share their happiness. Liverpool players share their delight on Instagram after dramatic late derby win over Everton